Submission to the Youth Justice (Monitoring Devices) Amendment Bill 2025
QNADA recently made a submission to the Youth Justice (Monitoring Devices) Amendment Bill 2025. The purpose of the Bill is to extend the electronic monitoring trial period by one year. While we are supportive of policies which aim to keep children out of custody, we are concerned that the proposed amendments will increase the criminalisation of children without improving community safety. As such, we did not support the bill.
Our submission argued that there is insufficient evidence to support extending the trial period considering that the literature on the use of electronic monitoring devices with children is, at best, mixed and that the trial has been extended multiple times yet has failed to provide evidence to support its effectiveness.
We also argued that the bill will not enhance community safety and instead will result in the further criminalisation and net-widening and, more broadly, policies which are punitive in nature generally do not provide a benefit to the community. We instead argued for policy and legislative responses focused on addressing the broader social factors which elevate the risk of a young person coming into contact with police or entering the youth justice system, including poverty, homelessness, family violence, and problematic substance use.
You can read the full submission here.